What Men's Work Actually Is

Men's work has become a widely used term with a correspondingly wide range of meanings — from the serious depth-psychological tradition that Robert Bly, James Hollis, and Bill Plotkin represent to weekend workshops marketed as transformative experiences with celebrity facilitators. Understanding what the term actually covers, where it came from, and what distinguishes genuine practice from marketing helps men find what will actually serve them.

Where it comes from

The men's work tradition has multiple roots. The mythopoetic men's movement of the 1980s and 90s — associated with Robert Bly, Michael Meade, James Hillman, and their gatherings at retreat centers across the United States — brought depth psychology and mythology together in a explicitly male framework for the first time. Bly's Iron John (1990) gave the movement its most widely read text.

Simultaneously, the clinical tradition was developing its understanding of specifically male psychology: Terry Real's work on male depression, Robert Glover's on the Nice Guy syndrome, the Jungian tradition's archetypal framework through Moore and Gillette's King, Warrior, Magician, Lover.

More recently, the trauma-informed tradition — Bessel van der Kolk, Peter Levine, Gabor Maté — has provided a somatic and neurobiological basis for the work that the original mythopoetic tradition lacked.

Connor Beaton's ManTalks represents the contemporary synthesis: the trauma-informed, somatic, relational, and community dimensions integrated into a practical framework for modern men.

What it involves in practice

Genuine men's work involves: honest self-examination in a relational context (not solo), community with other men doing the same thing, engagement with the body and somatic experience rather than only with ideas, the willingness to face what has been avoided, and sustained practice over time rather than one-off events.

What it does not require: any particular spiritual or religious belief, any specific political position, any uniform idea of what masculinity should look like. The best programs and practitioners are remarkably diverse in their approach and their participants.

What distinguishes genuine practice from marketing: the best practitioners are honest about what they can and cannot provide, have verifiable training and track records, encourage continued work rather than dependence on a single program, and measure success by changes in men's actual lives rather than the quality of the weekend experience.

Common Questions

Is men's work related to the men's rights movement?

No. They are categorically different and in many respects opposed. The men's rights movement focuses on perceived male disadvantage and externalizes responsibility. Men's work is about personal responsibility and interior development — the explicit recognition that many of men's difficulties are produced by male conditioning that men can choose to address.

Do I have to identify as having a problem to do men's work?

No. The men who get the most from it are often functional men who sense something is missing — not men in visible crisis. The work is developmental, not remedial. You don't need to be broken to want to deepen.

Books on This Topic

Iron John(1990)
Robert Bly
The book that started the modern men's movement. A mythological exploration of male initiation and the Wild Man archetype — still essential 35 years later.
Men's Work(2022)
Connor Beaton
A practical guide to facing your darkness, ending self-sabotage, and finding freedom — the manual ManTalks was built around.
Under Saturn's Shadow(1994)
James Hollis
The wounding and healing of men — a Jungian exploration of the psychological forces that shape male behavior and how men might begin to heal.
King, Warrior, Magician, Lover(1990)
Robert Moore & Douglas Gillette
The Jungian archetype framework at the heart of most men's work programs — the four masculine archetypes and how men access their mature power.

Coaches and Programs in the Directory

These practitioners work directly in the areas covered on this page.

CB
Connor Beaton
ManTalks
Founder of ManTalks, one of the leading men's mental health and self-leadership platforms globally. His book Men's Work has become a foundat…
BP
Bill Plotkin
Animas Valley Institute
Founder of Animas Valley Institute and one of the most influential voices in nature-based depth psychology. Plotkin's work on soul initiatio…
RR
Richard Rohr
Illuman
Franciscan friar, founder of the Center for Action and Contemplation, and co-founder of Illuman. One of the most widely-read Catholic writer…

Browse the Directory

Find coaches and programs working in these areas.

Masculinity & ManhoodIdentityShadow WorkBrotherhooddepth-psychology
Ready to find the right fit?

The Men's Work Directory is a curated list of coaches, programs, and retreats doing serious work. Browse by what you're dealing with.

Browse the Directory